Literary Criticism - Contemporary Tamil Literature
Topic started by Mani M. Manivannan (@ cpe-24-221-181-57.ca.sprintbbd.net) on Wed May 2 02:14:57 .
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
W. H. Auden wrote:
What is the function of a critic. So far as I am concerned, he can do me one or more of the following services:
1. Introduce me to authors or works of which I was hitherto unaware.
2. Convince me that I have undervalued an author or a work because I had not read them carefully enough.
3. Show me relations between works of different ages and cultures which I could never have seen for myself because I do not know enough and never shall.
4. Give a "reading" of a work which increases my understanding of it.
5. Throw light upon the process of artistic "making."
6. Throw light upon the releation of art to life, science, economics, ethics, religion, etc.
- "The Dyer's Hand and Other Essays" (Random House, Inc., 1972)
Cleanth Brooks added in his articles of faith "That in a successful work, form and content cannot be separated and that form is meaning."
These are useful definitions of literary criticism, perhaps descriptions of a formalist criticism. Of course, there are other types of criticisms such as the Deconstruction, Jungian or archetypal, Historical, Marxist, Biographical, Psychoanalytical, Ethnic (minority?), etc. There is always the reader's criticism that usually is a single reader's perspective on something that they read. I invite readers to post their criticisms of something that they have read using Auden's guidelines in mind. Excerpts from professional critics are also welcome.
Responses:
- Old responses
- From: Bhoori (@ c660409-a.frmt1.sfba.home.com)
on: Sat May 12 12:08:22
Devakachayakumar:
The memory you have about somebody saying that Mani is talking out of jealousy comes from my posting. I suggest that you dig up that posting up again and READ IT! Skimming it will cause confusions like this; hypothetical scenarios shouldnt be confused with reality.
- From: Bhoori (@ c660409-a.frmt1.sfba.home.com)
on: Sat May 12 12:33:21
þ°×™�œ‘Æ�ÀÑ:
…›�è ƒ¨€�€Æ™ �¯¨ ðÓÖ °€Ò™� Á¤�Æ þ�‘ºÅ ‡à¹°³. ‡à±Æ€° œÍÆ‘�¿ º¦™�‘ÀÖ À¬€Æ �€é —œ‘òî°‘� ‡à± �€°¿ ºíê ºÒ Øã™�ÃÅ —�‘¨™Žé‘þÌ ‡òì Á�ÚÅ ‡Í¢œÖ ˆíºª¥³. »éþ�‘ ƒ±Ö ŠòìÅ ‚¢œÍÆÅ ƒÖ€Ò ‡òì þ°‘òêÆ³. °ã›�è ÿ¯¨ —�‘¯þ¥ þº‘Žòéî; ƒ±Ö ŠÏ ב™ŽÆ´€° "�Úª ‚Œ¿ �‘ò—¥™øª" ½Í¹³ —�‘èã ב˿½ ƒÏ™Žé³ ‡òì þ°‘òêÆ³.
ƒ¹°´ °ã´±Ö º›� —ºìº×Ñ�äò ¸–Ö ºíêÆ ØÀÑœî›�è þµÑ€ÀÉ¥ñÅ µ¨¶€Ò€ÀÉ¥ñÅ ‡à°¿ºª¥€× ‡òé �¦¿º€¥ (€ù¿º‘±÷’ø) µÅ �€î×Ï™�Å þ°€× ‡òì µ‘ò µÅ½Žþéò. �¿º¦ µ‘Å ¶€î™�‘ت¥‘Ö ØÀÑœ�Ñ ŠÏ "�Ö§ÍÆÑ þÀ‘¦Ü" €×´³™—�‘¯¨°‘ò ØÀÑ�™Žé‘Ñ ‡òì Æ‘̑׳ ‡à°™ ˜¨Å. �¿º¦ ‡à³º€× �Ï´°‘ãÑ�äò …«Ñ¢�€Æ �î‘×�ÆÀ‘� ž¯¨Å. �°í� ŠÏ �íº€î …°‘Ì«À‘� À¬€Æ ƒ¿º¦ Ƒ̑׳ —œ‘ÖÒ™ ˜¨Å ‡òì ‡à± ƒÏ¹þ°ò. µÖÒ þ×€ãÆ‘� ÿ›�è �°í� ù€°Æ ב™ŽÆ´€° º‘Ñ™�ØÖ€Ò þº‘ÓÏ™Žé³. ƒÖ€Ò ‡òé‘Ö ¾Í °ò€î´°‘þî ˜ó‘ ‡òŽé‘Ñ ‡òì ¶€î´³ �°í�Å Øã™�Å ‡à± ƒÏ¿¼Ñ�þã‘ ‡òîþב.
�€é¹° ºªœÅ À¬ ‡òé �Ï´°‘ã€Ì¿ ºíê ƒ´°€�Æ �Ï´³™�€ã ‡à³×³ �Ï´°‘ã€Ì¿ ºíêÆ ØÀÑœî›�è ˜¥‘³ ‡òé ‡ò �Ï´€°þÆ Àì°Ó™Žé³ ‡òé‘׳ ÿ›�è þÆ‘�´±Ï™�Ò‘Å.
…›�è µ€¥ ‡î™� œíì ½Í¹³ —�‘èã �ö¥À‘� ƒÏ™Žé³. …›�è Àíé �Ï´³™�€ã¿ ºíê Ø×‘±™�Å ¶€ÒÇÕÅ µ‘ò ƒ¿þº‘³ ƒÖ€Ò. ¯¨Å œ¹±¿þº‘Å.
- From: §¾Å¸º¡ÂÌÁ÷ (@ 129.81.216.123)
on: Sat May 12 13:06:21
thank you for the information.
I will dig up and see. You may be right. There could be a possibility for my misunderstanding.
If my understanding is wrong, my apologies.
�€é¹° ºªœÅ À¬ ‡òé �Ï´°‘ã€Ì¿ ºíê ƒ´°€�Æ �Ï´³™�€ã ‡à³×³ �Ï´°‘ã€Ì¿ ºíêÆ ØÀÑœî›�è ˜¥‘³ ‡òé ‡ò �Ï´€°þÆ Àì°Ó™Žé³ ‡òé‘׳ ÿ›�è þÆ‘�´±Ï™�Ò‘Å.
Yes, I should have done it. However, to be honest with you, at this moement I am not able to follow who stands for what and said what in the past. Really sorry for the damping correlating capacity of my neurons on Who's Who.
I wish someone could post a review on something rather than living in the Vishnupuram waiting for Vishnu's next roaring rolling ;-)
- From: Satish (@ spider-wq073.proxy.aol.com)
on: Sat May 12 16:04:15
how many tamil authors get this kinda attention from readers like jeyamohan? may be jeyakanthan, sujatha and balakumaran?many authors are just there filling pages for many years and no one really cares.
- From: ÃÅ¢ Íó¾Ãõ (@ pa-bethelpark2a-530.pit.adelphia.net)
on: Sat May 12 19:04:05
ââ ±øÄ¡ì ¸Ê¾í¸ÙìÌõ ´§Ã ¾Ã¡Í¾¡ý ±ýÚ ¦º¡øÅÐ ºÃ¢ÂøÄ.
¨½ÂŢš¾í¸Ç¢ø ¦º¡øÄ§Åñʨ¾ Å¢¨ÃÅ¢ø ¦º¡ø¸¢§È¡õ.
Ð §ÀîÍìÌî ºÁõ. ±Ø¾ôÀð¼ §ÀîÍ ±ýÚ¾¡ý ¦¸¡ûǧÅñÎõ.
«îºÊì¸ôÀð¼ Òò¾¸§Á¡, ±Ø¾ôÀðÎ «îº¢ø §¸¡ì¸ôÀðÎ ÀÄÓ¨È
§º¡¾¨Éô À¢Ã¾¢¸û «îº¢¼ôÀðÎ À¢¨Æ¸û ºÃ¢À¡÷ì¸ôÀðÎ ¦ÅÇ¢ÅÕÀ¨Å.
(ýÛõ «ôÀÊ¡ «øÄÐ ±øÄ¡õ ¸½¢É¢Â¡¸¢Å¢ð¼¾¡ ¦¾Ã¢Â¡Ð.)
¯¾¡Ã½Á¡¸ ±ýÛ¨¼Â §ÀẢâÂ÷ ¸½¢ò¾øÓ¨È ¿£÷Á µð¼ Âø
(computational fluid dynamics) À¡¼ Ţâרâø º¡¾¡Ã½ò ¾ÅÚ¸û
¦ºöРŢÎÅ¡÷. Á¡½Å÷¸û ¿¡í¸§Ç «ùÅô§À¡Ð ÌÚ츢ðÎ
"³Â¡ «ó¾ ºÁýÀ¡ðÊý (equation) ¼ÐÀì¸õ ãýÈ¡ÅÐ À¡¸ò¨¾
Å¢ðÎÅ¢ðË÷¸û" ±ýÚ ¦º¡øÄ§ÅñÊ¢ÕìÌõ. ¬É¡ø «ÅÕ¼ý
´Õ ¬ö×ì¸ðΨà ±Ø¾¢ ÓÊôÀ¾üÌû ¾¡× ¾£÷óÐÅ¢Îõ! ´ô§À¡÷
¾¢ÈÉ¡öÅ¢ø (peer review) ´Õ À¢¨Æ¸¡½ôÀð¼¡Öõ ¦ÀÕò¾
«ÅÁ¡ÉÁ¡¸ì ¸ÕÐÅ¡÷.
¾ýÛ¨¼Â ¦ÀÂâø «îº¡Ìõ Òò¾¸ò¾¢ø À¢¨Æ¸¨Ç «ÛÁ¾¢ôÀÐ
"¦ºöÔ󦾡Ƣ§Ä ¦¾öÅõ" ±ýÚ À¢ýÚÅÕõ ÀñÀ¡ðÎ째
Óý¡ÉÐ.
------------------------
¦º¡øÀŨÃÅ¢¼ ¦º¡øÄôÀÎÅо¡ý Ó츢Âõ ±ýÀ¾¢ø ±ÉìÌõ
´ÃÇ× ´ôÒ¾ø ¯ñÎ. ¬Â¢Ûõ ¾ý¨Éò¾¡§É ¬öž¢ø ÁüÈ
ÀĨÃÔõÅ¢¼ ¸Î¨ÁÂ¡É ¾Ã¡º¡ø ¾ý¨Éò ¾¡§É ¿¢Ú츧ÅñÎõ
±ýÚõ ¿õÒ¸¢§Èý.
------------------------
º¡¾¡Ã½Á¡¸ô ÀÊìÌõ Á¡½Åý 70 º¾Å£¾õ ¦ÀüÈ¡§Ä
¦ÅÌÅ¡¸ô Ò¸Øõ ¬º¢Ã¢Â÷ ¾ÉìÌô À¢Êò¾ Á¡½Åý 95 º¾Å£¾õ
Á¾¢ô¦Àñ ¦ÀüÈ¡Öõ, "¦¸¡ïºõ ÓÂüº¢ò¾¢Õ󾡸 100
Å¡í¸¢Â¢Õì¸Ä¡§Á" ±ýÈ ¬¾í¸ò§¾¡Î¾¡ý §ÀÍÅ¡÷. Á½¢Ôõ
¦ƒÂ§Á¡¸¨É «ôÀÊò¾¡ý §¿¡ì̸¢È¡÷ ±ýÚ ¿¢¨É츢§Èý.
- From: Bhoori (@ c660409-a.frmt1.sfba.home.com)
on: Sun May 13 01:43:47
ÌØ: …›�è ƒ¨€�ÇÖ …èã �Ï´³ ‡ò ‡¯«›�€ãþÆ œ‘ѹ³ ƒÏ™Žé³. ‚î‘Ö �°ò —°‘ïþÆ‘ ‡ò �Ï´€° ‡±Ñ¿º³ þº‘Ö ƒÏ™Žé³. ;-) µ‘ñÅ ÿ›�è —œ‘Ö×€°´°‘ò —œ‘ÖŽþéò. ½´°�›�€ãÉÅ �¦°›�€ãÉÅ ŠþÌ °Ì‘�Ö ¶ì™�™˜¥‘³, ƒ€«Æ �̪€¥�äÖ …èã °ª¥¢Ÿ¿ »€Ý�€ã —ºÍ³º¨´°™˜¥‘³ ‡òì°‘ò —œ‘ÖŽþéò. �³ÚÅ ƒ¹° "¿ÐŒ¿ Î¥Ñ" ב°´€°þÆ µ‘ñÅ —œ‘ÖÓ ƒÏ¹þ°ò. �°î‘Ö°‘ò —óÆþÀ‘ùò ŠÏ ƒ¨€�ÇÖ "ÃÆÑ¢�" ‡òì ‡à±Æ€° À¬ —ºÍ³º¨´³º×€° ‚ªþœ»™Žþéò. �³ÚÅ À¬ ƒ€«Æ™ �¦°›�äÖ œ‘°‘Ì«À‘� ˆíº¨Å »€Ý�€ã —º‘Ϫº¨´°™ ˜¥‘³ ‡òì —œ‘ÖÓØª¨ »é� Øö®½Ì´±Ö »€Ý ƒÏ¿º°‘Ö —ó.Øò ƒ€«Æ™ �¦°›�äÖ …èã »€Ý�æÅ �¯¦™�¿º¥ þׯ¦Æþ° ‡òì —œ‘Ö׳ ‡î™� Ÿ´°À‘�¿ ½ÍÆØÖ€Ò. ‡ÖÒ‘™ �¦°›�æÅ ŠþÌ °Ì‘�Ö°‘ò ¶ì™�¿º¥þׯ¨Å ‡òì ƒ¹° "�‘ò—¥™ø¦Ö°‘ò" —œ‘ÖÓ ƒÏ¹þ°ò. ÿ›�è µ‘ò —œ‘Ö×€° ‡ÖÒ‘Å Š¿½™—�‘èŽëÑ�è. ‚î‘Ö �€¥�ÇÖ �¦°›�è ŠþÌ °Ì‘�Ö ¶ì™�¿º¥ þׯ¨Å ‡òº€° À왎ëÑ�è. �¦°›�è ‡¿þº‘³ þ×ì þ×ì °Ì‘Ÿ�äÖ ¶ì™�¿º¥ þׯ¨Å?
�¢�¥¿º¨Å ½´°�›�è ‡òî, ƒ€«Æ ƒ°â�äÖ �¢Ÿ¿ »€Ý, ƒÒ™�«¿ »€Ý ƒÏ¹°‘ÕÅ �³ �¯¦™�¿º¥ þׯ¦Æþ°. ²Ì‘ µ±ÇÖ ƒÒ™�«¿ »€Ý ƒÏ¹°‘Ö �€°ÉÅ �¯¦É›�è! ŠþÌ Ø´±Æ‘œÅ, ¸–Ö�äÖ …èã »€Ý�æ™� ƒì±¿ —º‘쿽 ‚�ÍÆÏ€¥Æ³, ƒ€«Æ ƒ°â�äÖ »€Ý�æ™�¿ —º‘쿺‘ãÑ ƒ°Ý‘�ÍÆÑ. �Ü×ãÚ°‘ò.
- From: N.K.Segar (@ 203.121.0.12)
on: Tue Jun 5 01:30:37
Dear friends,
We are still thinking of Jayakanthan, Sujata etc. Have we identified any new writers who will be taking our great Tamil literature to greater heights.
Recently, I happened to read Jayakanthan's new series in Makkal Osai, a weekly in Malaysia. I am shocked that the writing style is not impressive at all.
Please ponder.
Seagr
- From: Misguided Soul (@ bkj-cache83.jaring.my)
on: Tue Jun 5 04:07:18
What is this?????? Are we lost????
- From: jeyamohanb (@ )
on: Tue Nov 13 11:27:14
«ýÒ¨¼Â£÷
«Îò¾ÅÕ¼õ ƒÉÅâÁ¡¾õ ¾Á¢Æ¢ý Ó츢ÂÁ¡É Ä츢 ¬Ù¨ÁÔõ , «Æ¸¢ÂÄ¡ÇÕÁ¡É Ó ¾¨Ç º¢í¸õ ÌÈ¢òÐ ´Õ ¸Õò¾Ãí¨¸ ¿¼ò¾ ¦º¡ø Ò¾¢Ð º¢üÈ¢¾ú ¯ò§¾º¢òÐûÇÐ. ¸Õò¾Ãí¸õ º¢È¢Â «ÇÅ¢ø ¾¡ý ¯ò§¾º¢ì¸ô ÀðÎûÇÐ.º¢üÈ¢¾Æ¢ý ÀÄÅ£Éí¸û ¿¢¾¢ º¡÷ó¾¨Å. °ðÊ¢ø ,«Ð º£ºÉøÄ ±ýÀ¾É¡ø ,‚ ¿¡Ã¡Â½ÌÕÌÄõ ÄźÁ¡¸ ¸¢¨¼ìÌõ.¼Åº¾¢Ô¼ý º¢Ú ¿¢¾¢Ô¾Å¢Ôõ¦ºöÅ¡÷¸û.¯½×î ¦ºÄ׸¨Ç ¦º¡ø Ò¾¢Ð º¡÷À¢ø ¸ÅÉ¢òÐì ¦¸¡û§Å¡õ . Å¢Ã¢Å¡É Å¡º¸ô Àí§¸üÒìÌ ¦À¡ÐÅ¡É º¡ò¾¢Âõ ̨È× .¸¡Ã½õ ¾ü¸¡¸ °ðÊ Å¨Ã ÅÕÀÅ÷¸û ̨ÈÅ¡¸§Å ÕôÀ¡÷¸û.¦Àâ «ÇÅ¢ø ¿¼ò¾ ±í¸Ç¡ø ÓÊÅÐÁ¢ø¨Ä.¬¸ ¯ò§¾º¢ò¾¢ÕôÀÐ ´Õ º¢Ú ¬öÅÃí¸õ .¬÷ÅÓûÇ 20 Ó¾ø 30 Ũà Ä츢 ŢÁ⺸÷¸û, ¿ñÀ÷¸û Àí§¸üÚ ´Õ Ţš¾õ.¾¨Çº¢í¸ò¾¢ý ÀüÀÄ ¾Çí¸¨ÇôÀüÈ¢ 10 ¸ðΨøû ¾Â¡Ã¢ì¸ ÓÊÔÁ¡ ±ýÀ§¾ ¾¢ð¼õ.¸ðΨâý ÓýŨÃ׸¨Ç «íÌ Óý¨ÅòРŢš¾¢òÐ ÓØ¨Á ¦ºöÐ ¦¸¡ûÇ ÓÂø§Å¡õ. «Åü¨È áø ÅÊÅ¢ø ¦ÅǢ¢¼ ¯ò§¾ºõ ¯ûÇÐ.ÀÄ ¾Çí¸¨Ç §º÷ó¾ 12 ¿ñÀ÷¸Ç¢¼õ ¸ðΨà §¸ðÎû§Ç¡õ. áø ¸¢¨¼ôÀÐ º¢ÃÁõ ±ýÀ¾É¡ø ô§À¡Ð¾¡ý «Åü¨È ¦ƒÃ¡ìŠ ±ÎòÐ ±øÄ¡ÕìÌõ «ÛôÀ¢ÅÕ¸¢§È¡õ.¸Õò¾Ãí¸ Å¢„Âò¾¢ø Á¢¸ô¦Àâ ¦ºÄ× Ð¾¡¦ÉýÚ Àθ¢ÈÐ. ¸Õò¾ÃíÌ «§É¸Á¡¸ ƒÉÅâ Á¡¾õ Ãñ¼¡õ Å¡Ãõ ¿¼ìÌõ. ¦ÅûÇ¢ ºÉ¢ »¡Â¢Ú ±ýÚ ãýÚ ¿¡ð¸Ç¢ø .¦Á¡ò¾õ 6 «Ãí̸û .»¡Â¢Ú Á¾¢Âõ ÓÊŨ¼Ôõ.
Àí§¸üÀ¾üÌ ¸ð¼½õ ø¨Ä .¬É¡ø ¦Á¡ò¾õ 4 ¿¢Àó¾¨É¸û ¯ñÎ. 1]¸ñÊôÀ¡¸ ÅÕ¨¸¨Â ÓýÜðʧ ¯Ú¾¢ ¦ºö§ÅñÎõ.«ÛÁ¾¢ øÄ¡Áø ±Å¨ÃÔõ «¨ÆòÐ ÅÃìܼ¡Ð.2] ±øÄ¡ «Ãí̸ǢÖõ ¸ñÊôÀ¡¸ ¸ÄóÐ ¦¸¡ûÇ §ÅñÎõ.±ó¾ «Ãí¨¸Ôõ ±ì¸¡Ã½ò¾¡Öõ ¾Å¢÷ôÀÐ «ÛÁ¾¢ì¸ô À¼ Á¡ð¼¡Ð.3]«Ãí¸¢Öõ ¸Õò¾Ãí¸ ¿¡ð¸Ç¢ø ¦ÅÇ¢§ÂÔõ ¸ñÊôÀ¡¸ ÁÐ «Õó¾Ä¡¸¡Ð. 4]¾É¢ôÀð¼ ¾¡ì̾ø¸û ¾Å¢÷ì¸ôÀ¼ §ÅñÎõ.
±øÄ¡Å¢¾Á¡É Å¢ÁâºÉí¸ÙÌõ ¼õ¾Ã ÓÂø§Å¡õ.´ðÎ ¦Á¡ò¾Á¡¸ ¾Á¢úî ÝÆÄ¢ø ¾¨Çº¢í¸ò¨¾ ¸ÅÉôÀÎòÐÅÐ ¾¡ý §¿¡ì¸õ .§¿Ã¢ø Åà ÓÊ¡¾Å÷¸û ¸ðΨøû «ÛôÀ¢É¡ø À¢ÃÍÃòÐìÌõ Ţš¾òÐìÌõ ¯¾Å¢Â¡¸ ÕìÌõ
¦¾¡¼÷ÒìÌ
S ARUNMOZHI NANGAI
HEAD POST OFFICE
THUCKALAY
TAMIL NADU
INDIA
629175
PH 04652 227049
jeyamohanb@rediffmail.com
soll_pudhidhu@hotmail.com
Tell your friend about this topic
Want to post a response?
Back to the Forum