HJ & his melodies

**A.ANAND** · 18th January 2005, 06:43 AM

chellamy is 1 of biggest musical hit 2004?????????????
i can't beliaf it!!(NAMBAVE MUDIYILE)
it's normal average album from hj.not a super duper hits!!

**Google Adsense** · 18th January 2005 06:43 AM

**NagaS** · 18th January 2005, 12:04 PM

Yes anand ... I also rate Chellamae as average, But it was a big musical hit

Somehow, I feel HJ is yet to produce a real melody,. Vidyasagar has done it more than once in the last couple of years and Yuvan is fast picking-up ... But surprisingly, HJ gets all high profile projects

(I know the first response I am going to get for this post., Let me answer in advance ... No, I can't accept "vaseegara" as a soulful melody, It had a good pallavi and very bad charaNams, which were nothing but urainadai !)

NagaS

**magix** · 18th January 2005, 05:40 PM

NagaS..
seems there's a classical number in Anniyan.

kaetu paarkalaam.

**NagaS** · 18th January 2005, 06:34 PM

magix, no problem, I can wait

But looking at HJ's trend, this time he will try to copy 'maargazhith thingaL allavaa' or some other ARR classical number

)

NagaS

**Music4Ever** · 19th January 2005, 12:32 AM

PoovE vAi pEsum pOdhu seems like a nice melody from HJ. I believe, however, that it's inspired from an IR Nayagan number and also has traces of an ARR Thenali number. Some of the remarks on HJ here seem to be a tad uncharitable, though. His songs azhagiya theeyE, vaseegara, uyirin uyirE, ennai konjam, etc are all superb. Chellamae songs are good too.

**magix** · 19th January 2005, 07:34 AM

Music4Ever,
Poovae Vaai Pesumbothu is perhaps his MOST inspired song!

It was a cocktail of Netru Illadha Maatram (Pudhiya Mugam) and Swaasame (Thenali)..

**ar rahmans** · 19th January 2005, 08:54 AM

povee vai peesumm pothu copied from...

heal the world michael jackson

heheheh

RR · 19th January 2005, 09:38 AM

My favorite HJ melodies: vaseegara,venmathiye,mudhar kanave,pinju thendrale (mainly for sandhya). 'poove vaa pesum podhu' is bordering on 'urainadai' (to borrow NagaS terminology), IMO. 'pinju thendrale' is sort of too

(well, tell me when the digression has gone enough. I'll move it to a HJ topic.)

**NOV** · 19th January 2005, 09:52 AM

Mudhar kanave mudhar kanave - when it first came out - was said to be a carbon copy of Narumugaiye narumugaiye.
What made it worse was that the singers of both songs were the same - Bombay Jaysree and Unnikrishnan!

venmathi was of course accused of resembling chellakkiligalaam palliyile.

**Music4Ever** · 19th January 2005, 10:24 AM

Magix, it is indeed surprising that Poove vAi pEsum podhu is inspired from nEtru illadha mAtram. I will have to listen to both closely

I agree about the SwAsamE part. I also believe Poove vAi pesum podhu is a major inspiration from Nee oru kAdhal sangeetham.

Nov, your observations are interesting, but whoever made the accusations are probably HCARRUF (Hard core arr uncharitable fans)