Maestro Ilaiyaraja New Albums 2011 - Hello Jaihind / Sri Rama Rajyam

[par]

Gokul / Jai,

I don't see any difference between forum members expressing their views here and with Karthik expressing his views. It is just that he expresses them in a blog. I don't see why that should make his views any more important than those of yours!!! I think we should take it in the spirit of 'one more view of the album' rather than "oh i was so expecting his review!!!" type of thing. As I said, it is just one point of view and which is in no superior or inferior to what is being discussed here.

Good point.

But why are we not applying the same logic to Charu Niveditha? Why are we calling him crazy, dog, etc.?

par,

Charu's agenda is clear to everyone except to those who want to turn a blind eye I would more than willing to give the benefit to Charu had he just been expressing his views and not deliberately say stuff like 'Paa makes Raja a joker in North' and stuff like that. In case of Karthik, we can have difference of opinion with his reviews but again it is quite clear that he doesn't push an agenda.

(I am surprised that I have to explain this I thought it would be quite obvious to those who read Charu and those who read Karthik.)

Charu doesn't like Raaja's music and calls it trash. Some of us don't like Charu's opinion and call him crazy.
Both cases are at the same level in my mind. Throwing mud

Why should we go that low?

[par]

Par,
ungaluku reply panna maten...
Anavasiyama idam waste agum.......

Exactly my point
If I don't like Charu, I will keep away from him.

[tvsankar]

Shankar,
Unga list ai partha - 80s ai thaandi varalai pola irukae...

Vedham pudhidhu - film la - paiyan Sathyaraj parthu solvan - naan karai yeriten.. neenga angaeyae irukaelae nu..

andha madhiri,,
IR - 2010 varai music seinju irukar..
Neenga inum 80s list layae irukeengalae..

apo epadi ......... romba kashtam shankar...

Neraiya Homework ungaluku iruku....

90s Raajavai kelunga... Then 2000 ku vango... pesalam...

[Sanjeevi]

Charu doesn't like Raaja's music and calls it trash. Some of us don't like Charu's opinion and call him crazy.
Both cases are at the same level in my mind.

Objection your honour

you are toally wrong. If anybody said here "Charu's Zero degree novel is worst?" or "His serious articles are exactly a comedy piece?". We told against him for his statement on IR and his music. period

[Sureshs65]

par,

I will tell this slowly one last time and I hope you will understand.

There is a major difference between saying that you don't like 'Paa' songs and saying 'Paa is the laughing stock of North India. Check with your friends and if that is not the case I will remove half of my lovely mustache' or some such thing.

If the difference between these two statements is clear, we don't have an argument. In case it is not clear, then also we don't have an argument.

[irir123]

par,

I will tell this slowly one last time and I hope you will understand.

There is a major difference between saying that you don't like 'Paa' songs and saying 'Paa is the laughing stock of North India. Check with your friends and if that is not the case I will remove half of my lovely mustache' or some such thing.

If the difference between these two statements is clear, we don't have an argument. In case it is not clear, then also we don't have an argument.

suresh65 - IMHO, both charu and par need to be safely ignored - giving them and their opinions importance actually gives them credibility!

[Sureshs65]

Very true irir123. And desist I shall.

[sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar]

oru levelukku mela IR pathi analysis pannum intha makkalukku innamum charu oru manushanaaga paduvathu is surprising to me! IR's famelight is so powerful that we are / were thinking that he is the only one in whole of TN to make fun on raja(leave alone the 'few' ARR fans) thats the 1st mistake. he may dislike and totally discard raja, thats ok (infact thats not the case, he has written that he liked thiruvaasagam and nandalala) vimarsanangal sagajam thaan.

but look at the recent issue in mudam arasu bathilgal. the reader asked a question that did charu says hat IR DONT KNOW to compose music? what say abt it? the arasu answer is, charu is looked upon like a joker, in literary community.

charu, with all anger repented and tried to showcase(but in poor vain ) his 'unexisting' fame at kerala!!! but the problem is he never corrected his statement. he didnt try to say "நான் இளையராஜாவுக்கு இசையமைக்கவே தெரியாது என்று சொல்லவில்லை, அவரின் இசையை கடுமையாக விமரிசித்தேன், அவ்வளவுதான்" and that is too bad right?


இளையராஜாவின் இசையை கடுமையாக விமர்சிப்பதும்,
அவருக்கு (மருந்துக்கு கூட )இசையமைக்கவே தெரியாது என்று சொல்வதும், முற்றிலும் வெவ்வேறு. இதற்கு மேலும் சாரு நிவதிதாவை ஆதரிப்பவர்களை என்னென்று சொல்வது ? நல்ல வேலை, தமிழ்நாட்டில் மொத்தமும் ஒரு முப்பத்திநாலு பேருக்கு தான் சாறு என்றால் யார் என்று தெரியும்

[cry_sandiego]

1.30- 2.05 in Edhaya Baagilu -- Too Cool !! Raja Raja Thaan.

[MADDY]

IR's famelight is so powerful that we are / were thinking that he is the only one in whole of TN to make fun on raja(leave alone the 'few' ARR fans)

//eh? .......puriyala sakala - enna solreenga? //