Favorite Scenes/Songs from THALAIVAR Rajini films #3

**hamid** · 11th December 2009, 11:19 AM

Grouch

I agree.. I have voted for that

shall we will give 2 day deadline for this poll and request all to give top 10 comedy scenes of Rajini?

**Google Adsense** · 11th December 2009 11:19 AM

**hamid** · 11th December 2009, 11:22 AM

Originally Posted by hamid

Did he make the right choice of moving towards commercial cinema??

Grouch, your thoughts on this

**groucho070** · 11th December 2009, 11:32 AM

Originally Posted by hamid

Did he make the right choice of moving towards commercial cinema??

Grouch, your thoughts on this

*Grouch scratches his beard and sips coffee staring vacantly at nothing in front of him*

Well, Hamid, intha mathiri discussion ellam no use. TFI-la varugura ottumotha films-um commercial thaane. If I am not wrong, his MM, BOK, 6 to 60 ellam hits-thane? They are commercial films too.

I suppose you mean, class film as oppose to mass. While hubbers may fight over the definition, Rajini himself has a set of his own when he confessed during the fans meet that he like to be a "class" film actor. I suspect there is a regret within him that he did not continue on the path set forth through those films.

It's not too late. He can start Mach III or IV, whichever phase you would like to break, and start doing strong roles. His age is a great excuse to do majestic roles.

**hamid** · 11th December 2009, 11:49 AM

Grouch,

fans meet.. exactly thats what i want.. he said he changed his path for fans.. (It sounded like he regretted that decision..he simply put the blame on fans which may not be right.. He chose films like that and people loved him.. thats it.. Note : people accepted his 6-60..)

But in Kamal function he said he smartly choose this path so that he can be successful.. which is contradictory to his earlier statement...

anbd IMO he will definitely be successful even if he havent changed his path..

reg commercial films i agree to your point.... but what I meant is.. selecting variety of roles, not the hero-worship ones all the time..

he along with this directors and producers have took the fans in this direction and now it might not be possible to go back..

yes.. age (and to an extent Amithabh's roles) can be used as a excuse to change the path.. lets hope for that.. but the chances are very little..

**Plum** · 11th December 2009, 12:02 PM

hamid, konjam explicit-A sollunga. adhAvadhu, commercial path edukkalainA, class acting-layum kamal-ai minji iruppArnu solla varIngaLA? Depending on your response, we'll get Thirumaran to respond to you

**Plum** · 11th December 2009, 12:08 PM

Seriously, I would definitely like Rajni to do what Amitabh is doing now ( I mean in films, not the jatti viLambarams that Amit-ji stars in) and shut the north indies' mouth for ever that "only Amitji" can do such roles.

**hamid** · 11th December 2009, 12:14 PM

Plum,

if that is what you want to infer I dont have problems with that..

anyway let me try to put it clear...

1. Did Fans didnt really force him to change path?
2. what will his position be if he hasnt changed his path?
3. Is that a right decision?

IMO Even if he hasnt changed his path he would have been successful and will be a bigger star
(bigger than Kamal or not - maybe or maybe not..but he wont be far from Kamal.. thats for sure.. but, donot make this as the point of argument.. I afraid only hate discussion will start then.. )

One important reason for making this point as a Rajini fan is.. the argument put against him most of the time is he is just a mass actor.. he cant act in so called class films.. and the worst part is he(rajini) himself expressses that in public..

**groucho070** · 11th December 2009, 12:17 PM

Originally Posted by Plum

Seriously, I would definitely like Rajni to do what Amitabh is doing now ( I mean in films, not the jatti viLambarams that Amit-ji stars in) and shut the north indies' mouth for ever that "only Amitji" can do such roles.

Amen to that, brother. Put his heart and mind to it, he can blow any NI Jis out of the screen!!!

**hamid** · 11th December 2009, 12:18 PM

Originally Posted by Plum

( I mean in films, not the jatti viLambarams that Amit-ji stars in)

One more question which is in my mind for a long time.

Why Rajini and Kamal havent acted in any ads so far? ( I do remember long back Rajini acted in an ad which explains about Polio.. that cannot be categorized as ad IMO..)

Almost all the smaller stars except them act in ads and endorse products in TFI.

**AudazJay** · 11th December 2009, 12:19 PM

Originally Posted by hamid

Plum,

if that is what you want to infer I dont have problems with that..

anyway let me try to put it clear...

1. Did Fans didnt really force him to change path?
2. what will his position be if he hasnt changed his path?
3. Is that a right decision?

IMO Even if he hasnt changed his path he would have been successful and will be a bigger star
(bigger than Kamal or not - maybe or maybe not..but he wont be far from Kamal.. thats for sure.. but, donot make this as the point of argument.. I afraid only hate discussion will start then.. )

One important reason for making this point as a Rajini fan is.. the argument put against him most of the time is he is just a mass actor.. he cant act in so called class films.. and the worst part is he(rajini) himself expressses that in public..

That's his humility talking sar!