COPYING - IN TAMIL FILM HISTORY - PART2

**Scale** · 10th April 2009, 11:24 PM

rrprasad,

On a similar note I am also checking from thenali for a trumpet connection. Except the african heavy beats & chorus the base tune can be said indianized and it always shifts from point to point the picturization also vindicates in that sense. Whereas rum bum is BLUE's written all over exact replica of Guitar boogie on vocal version. to make it crisp and clear 7 8 naatkal & 1'o clock in charanam...looped.

Hulkster,

Hello Mr. Ethirkatchi - Well I dont say that is Indianized. Except the prelude and you can even stretch all the piano parts. Its wholly accepted fact that the tune is original and listen to the Ist interludes show me something like this in rumbum a verse type...

Mannai vaergal pirinthaalum,
Vinnai neelam pirinthaalum,
Kannai manigal pirinthaalum,
Unnai naan piriyillai,
Sangam Tamilai pirinthaalum,
Sattham isaiyai pirinthaalum,
Thaalam sruthiyai pirinthaalam

Wondering why Mani showed it in cinema screen... Still this have found a place in everyone lifted list but not rum bum.

**Google Adsense** · 10th April 2009 11:24 PM

**rprasad** · 11th April 2009, 01:49 AM

Hi Scale,

I have listened to the guitar boogie multiple versions and i still cannot find any direct similarity to the Rum Bum song. Ofcourse traces are there since it is the same genre and style with similar instruments with tRumpet being added in IR version. I think IR has suffciently worked on it to make it a distinct song. In short it is no exact replica as you claim. Even i try to sing the boogie tune with words it does not resemble the IR song at all. I dont know what you are listening to. Ofcourse since it is the Blues genre and is not IR's own there will be simialrity in notes as i acknowledged earlier. But the tune is different and even the preludes and interludes are reworked.
I wonder why Karthick of INETK did not put it on his site if he felt it was a copy. i am sure he must have heard the boogie version since this is a popular genre and very distinct sound.

**Hulkster** · 11th April 2009, 07:48 AM

Scale i got nothing else to say. I accept that the initial prelude is inspired but the tune except for the fact that it is of rock and roll genre does not resemble any part of yakitoori boogie. Like i said it is the same as hello mr ethirkachi. You could feel that the song is preceded by the piano prelude but the tune remains totally original. Same case.

**Scale** · 11th April 2009, 10:20 AM

Okay Guys! Thanks for your feedback. Lets move on....

**Scale** · 14th April 2009, 02:06 AM

Thank you Mr. Bill Halley and Comets

@0.35 - Rhythm & Blues Country Swing:

@1.02 -

Full song: and watch the trumpet@1.08,1.25 (no place to say Raaja improvised with instruments) girl, swing dance. Its a blatant lift!

A very close color version to Rum Bum Bum in terms of picturization (if tho exists) will be excavated soon.