COPYING - IN TAMIL FILM HISTORY - PART2

**thamizhvaanan** · 21st December 2008, 09:53 PM

Dinesh, why dont u say Rahman copied himself from aadi paaru mangaatha

**Google Adsense** · 21st December 2008 09:53 PM

**dinesh2002** · 21st December 2008, 11:13 PM

Its something that came up while i was chatting with a fren of mine. He was quite known in Telugu industry. so he came up with this, so i listened, and i did find some similarity in it.

ofcource the loop is there, and singer. normally ARR starts a trend, and never follow them. thats y im shocked.

he should have used a diferent singer or atleast a new loop representing rain drops.....

if HJ was in the subject im sure everyone would have agreed huh.... LOL

**SoftSword** · 22nd December 2008, 11:32 AM

yes, this movie nandhu was telecasted in Kalaignar TV yesterday and when i heard this song, i sensed it to be rahmans beat which i have heard very long before...
Then the first thing came to my mind was "aadippaaru mangaatthaa..."

and more, in one of the scenes the background music sounded like an exact rip off of "muthu"... which i guess use to come when they show ponnambalam... my friend caught this resemblence for me...

**dinesh2002** · 22nd December 2008, 06:42 PM

Originally Posted by SoftSword

yes, this movie nandhu was telecasted in Kalaignar TV yesterday and when i heard this song, i sensed it to be rahmans beat which i have heard very long before...
Then the first thing came to my mind was "aadippaaru mangaatthaa..."

and more, in one of the scenes the background music sounded like an exact rip off of "muthu"... which i guess use to come when they show ponnambalam... my friend caught this resemblence for me...

yes, could be high possibilities. Coz its after all by Mani Sharma... :P

Ohh, this movie has a Tamil version as well?? didint know that!!

But nevertheless, its a good song too though.

**music man** · 23rd December 2008, 06:31 AM

Originally Posted by dinesh2002

Originally Posted by SoftSword

yes, this movie nandhu was telecasted in Kalaignar TV yesterday and when i heard this song, i sensed it to be rahmans beat which i have heard very long before...
Then the first thing came to my mind was "aadippaaru mangaatthaa..."

and more, in one of the scenes the background music sounded like an exact rip off of "muthu"... which i guess use to come when they show ponnambalam... my friend caught this resemblence for me...

yes, could be high possibilities. Coz its after all by Mani Sharma... :P

Ohh, this movie has a Tamil version as well?? didint know that!!

But nevertheless, its a good song too though.

Dinesh...................Hey................Congra ts da...............U got a CD from MAdhushree........U r really lucky.......Hmmmm.......Its really a surprise as a leading playback singer has send her brand new CD to you.....

It means she is following each and every work of you.....Hats off....Enjoy.....Nalla iru thambi.....

**dinesh2002** · 23rd December 2008, 09:27 PM

Originally Posted by music man

Originally Posted by dinesh2002

Originally Posted by SoftSword

yes, this movie nandhu was telecasted in Kalaignar TV yesterday and when i heard this song, i sensed it to be rahmans beat which i have heard very long before...
Then the first thing came to my mind was "aadippaaru mangaatthaa..."

and more, in one of the scenes the background music sounded like an exact rip off of "muthu"... which i guess use to come when they show ponnambalam... my friend caught this resemblence for me...

yes, could be high possibilities. Coz its after all by Mani Sharma... :P

Ohh, this movie has a Tamil version as well?? didint know that!!

But nevertheless, its a good song too though.

Dinesh...................Hey................Congra ts da...............U got a CD from MAdhushree........U r really lucky.......Hmmmm.......Its really a surprise as a leading playback singer has send her brand new CD to you.....

It means she is following each and every work of you.....Hats off....Enjoy.....Nalla iru thambi.....

Hey man... thanks allot for the warm wishes... i was surprised and glad some 1 wished me

...

and thanks for that aanandha kaneer too

**vasanth2006** · 2nd January 2009, 11:20 AM

I came across this...

I couldn't find similarities for Kangal irnadal

.....but i see the similarities in Al thotta poobathi....

p.s: That ilamai kolam song is one of my fav....

**Renault** · 2nd January 2009, 10:08 PM

Originally Posted by vasanth2006

I came across this...

I couldn't find similarities for Kangal irnadal

.....but i see the similarities in Al thotta poobathi....

p.s: That ilamai kolam song is one of my fav....

Vasanth, no wonder in this... Kangal Irandaal and Chinna Kannan belong to the same raaga Reethigowlai.

The song that stuck my mind on hearing Kangal Irandaal was another IR masterpiece Reethigowlai, viz Thalaiyai Kuniyum Thaamaraiyee . a Raghuvaran film, I guess.

**app_engine** · 8th January 2009, 08:39 PM

A couple of weeks back I was listening to the radio station tuned by my son on car (FM 96.3 Detroit) and an old song got played.

The tune was exact replica of the following portion of an old TF song :

"நான் தன்னந்தனிக்காட்டு ராஜா
என் தோட்டத்தில் எத்தனை ரோஜா
நான் தீராத விளையாட்டுப்பிள்ளை
என் தொட்டிலில் எத்தனை முல்லை, முல்லை"

(Don't remember the movie's name, a well-known TMS song; also could not get the title of the western song played on radio)

**viraajan** · 8th January 2009, 09:11 PM

Folks,

The following pieces of music strongly remind me of the songs/music in Tamil Fill. I've found out the music that sounds similar to the 1st one given below. The second one strongly reminds me of a tamil song/music. Can someone please help me out!

1. Is this inspired one or just a coincidence? (Of course the duration is too short)

http://www.fileden.com/files/2008/5/...34/2%20Hrt.mp3

2. This one I'm not able to find out. Pls listen to this and let me know if it rings a bell to you.

http://www.fileden.com/files/2008/5/...4/Smr%20Rd.mp3

Thanks
VR