carnatic music- the eternal bliss

**wrap07** · 2nd February 2009, 10:40 AM

//

hi// if you want lyrics, you can post in that threads and there are giants here who will get it in no time. please mention the needed details. thanks for your interest.

**Google Adsense** · 2nd February 2009 10:40 AM

**bhava** · 2nd February 2009, 12:53 PM

my interest is to know about renditions of songs and musicians.

**wrap07** · 2nd February 2009, 01:41 PM

ok. i will narrate my experiences and my favourites. It may not be an universal opinion. Because, Carnatic music has undergone change over the years. I am familar mostly with GNB/Semmangudi/madurai mani concerts. These were part of CDS & dowloaded material also.

**bhava** · 2nd February 2009, 02:35 PM

thanks

. happy for your response.
can you list gnb renditions and your comments

**wrap07** · 2nd February 2009, 03:17 PM

sure. but dont take me to be an expert. these are just my humble opinions and what i felt.

Vinayaka - hamsadvani-patnam subramaniam iyer krthi
rendered in his style a pure delight.

Maragatavallim- Kambhoji-Dikshitar
To the best of my knowledge, i have not come across any other rendering apart from GNB. Raga alapana will be mind boggling. unfortunately only few recordings are available.

Sri Subramanyaya Namasthae-Kambhoji-Dikshitar
masterpiece of Dikshitar. a masterpiece from GNB too

Raga Sudha Rasa- andolika- Thyagaraja
a masterpiece and a to someextent monopoly by GNB.

Maaramanan-Hindolam-papanasam sivan
Tamadamen swami- todi-Papanasam sivan
classic and my favourites

Mansa etulo- Malayamarutham-Thyagaraja

Paliinchu kamkshi-Madhyamavathi-Shyama sastri

Marivere-Anandabhairavi-Shyama sastri
beautiful rendering and one of my favourites.

Lot more are there. I have listed a few.

**bhava** · 2nd February 2009, 03:41 PM

thank you so much D

you are right abt Maragatavallim. i also think the same. This song is new to me as also few above listed. i request you to list out his renditions which will be helpful to me.

**bhava** · 2nd February 2009, 05:09 PM

kindly give me famous composition of papanasam sivan please.

**wrap07** · 3rd February 2009, 12:05 PM

some more:-
Thyagaraja krithis
sobhillu-jaganmohini
Maurukelara-jayanthsri
Dharini Telusukonti-suddasaveri
(classic rendition)
sarasa samadana-kapi narayni
Evantivasu deivamu-sahana

this covers some of his renditions. lots more.

**bhava** · 3rd February 2009, 01:09 PM

thanks again for your time & efforts

**wrap07** · 3rd February 2009, 01:12 PM

regarding papanasam sivan krithis, i will mention what i know.

Kaa vaa vaa- varali
karpagame-madhyamavathi
parathpara-vachaspathi
enna thavam seithanai-kapi
amba manamkaninthu- panthuvarali
kana vendamo-sriranjani
nee irangayenil-attana
kannanai pani maname-shanmugapriya

He is called rightly called thamiz thyagaraja. manathai negizha vaikkum padalgal. His krithis are also very huge.