Which MD is best suited for Rajini?

[narayanan]

its coz Mani Ratnam was there

FYI, Murattukalai was SP.Muthuraman. Rajini did only one movie in the Mani-IR combo. If the combo did'nt work good, there would'nt have been an association for 17 years (Kavikkuyil -> Veera). Infact the first Rahman-Rajini movie was in 1995.

IR would have composed another tabla/tavil base song

So what ? as long as the song is good, why would I be bothered about it ? If the song sucks, would a new instrument invented specifically for the movie make any difference to me ?

[dinesh2002]

its coz Mani Ratnam was there

FYI, Murattukalai was SP.Muthuraman. Rajini did only one movie in the Mani-IR combo. If the combo did'nt work good, there would'nt have been an association for 17 years (Kavikkuyil -> Veera). Infact the first Rahman-Rajini movie was in 1995.

IR would have composed another tabla/tavil base song

So what ? as long as the song is good, why would I be bothered about it ? If the song sucks, would a new instrument invented specifically for the movie make any difference to me ?

FYKI, he was talking about STANDARD...not TASTE...that is why i brought MANI RATNAM in.... there is a big difference between Poduvaga song & Rakamma song...both SOUNDS VERY GOOD...but the STYLE & STANDARD r diff!!!!

[tvsankar]

The topic is

WHich MD is best suited for Rajini's Movies !!

ARR worked in 3 movies only.In this list, 2 of them are only suited. Baba is not accepted ny the public.

In the case of MSV,
He also worked in some movies.L don't know the details,

In the case of IR,
He worked a lot of moveis. What is it means?

IR is accepted for Rajini's movies by the public.
At the time, each and every film was expected by the public for IR and Rajini combo !!! This is true !!!

As a reference of the topic, IR is mostly suited for RAjini's movies.

With Love,
Usha Sankar.

[thumburu]

If Maddy doesn't have anything sensible to counter argue,he resorts to his fav pasttime of dragging IR Fans. Give us a break. Will you?and Dinesh, will u pls stop addressing me as "maapu" or thoppu.
Hub etiquette demands it. BTW, Iam not a "he".
Now, coming to the topic,
IR is the only MD who has addressed different dimensions of Rajini as an actor -
[ be it an amma/thangachi sentiment or lost lover or a loverboy lost in love or pining for an unrequited love . his delectable "thimirthanam" [Oh how I miss this Rajini !!!] - you name a mood, Raja would have covered it.
This is a fact that cannot be refuted. ARR or Deva or VS simply wERE not existing during Rajini's golden acting period .
How many varieties can we expect in an uni dimensional super star's films other than "thudipaadalgaL" or boring upadesa paadalGal?
ARR fans can just chill.
It is as simple as how IR can no where figure
if somebody were to discuss a SJSurya's or
Shahrukhkhan's songs or even the great Shivaji's songs

[dinesh2002]

ohhh..thumburu ur a gal va.... sorry ye... yes thumburu.... if Rajini's golden days were with IR....so wut about the Rajini NOW???? its selfish to tell IR was the 1 with Rajini during his best days...coz even untill now Rajini is doing good...infact better than in 1980s...and its ARR & Deva is the 1 composing music for nowdays Rajini.... and ofcource u know wut response were for Batsha,Annamalai,Muthu & Padaiyappa movies & audio.... infact Deva was the 1 created the trend for a Terrific Theme Music for Rajini.... and ARR improvise that Theme music in many ways.... Baba & Chandramuki might be the weak albums of Rajini albums in since Batsha ....coz both the albums were diff in script ....

[S.Balaji]

Thumburu and others....

When RK was at his peak, only IR was ruling and obviously the credit went to him but it in noway undermines ARR's abilities as a composer...
Given 3 chances, I think he did extremely well for all the 3 and all were super hits.....

ARR by no means inferior .....

but today , when we see RK movies, most of them were IR and naturally our assessment of best composer goes to IR only

Now someone will open a similar thread for Kamal also !

[dinesh2002]

Thumburu and others....

When RK was at his peak, only IR was ruling and obviously the credit went to him but it in noway undermines ARR's abilities as a composer...
Given 3 chances, I think he did extremely well for all the 3 and all were super hits.....

ARR by no means inferior .....

but today , when we see RK movies, most of them were IR and naturally our assessment of best composer goes to IR only

Now someone will open a similar thread for Kamal also !

superbly answered !!!

[MADDY]

guys guys.......please stop it...thumburu, wat is the need to argue with ppl. who have closed their minds on ARR??

idhu thevaya ramakrishna???? IR v/s ARR fight never ending pola irukku....

Balaji, really priviliged to see ur post praising ARR......i guess MSV fans are not that bad either

[Ramakrishna]

guys guys.......please stop it...thumburu, wat is the need to argue with ppl. who have closed their minds on ARR??

idhu thevaya ramakrishna???? IR v/s ARR fight never ending pola irukku....

Well i am trying to unite IR fans with ARR fans

[MADDY]

Well i am trying to unite IR fans with ARR fans

ippadiye pesi pesi odamba rana galam aakkitangale........ ........kai pilla escapu....