Point is "dont take the moral high ground." From time immemorial no one has been above copying.Quote:
Originally Posted by NormalMan
Printable View
Point is "dont take the moral high ground." From time immemorial no one has been above copying.Quote:
Originally Posted by NormalMan
serail killerum irukkaan. Jeppadi thirudanum irukkaan. Rendu perukkume thookku dhanadanai kudukkara sattam ezhudhungapppa
Aadukalam (2010)
Music Director: Prakash Kumar GV
Actors: Dhanush, Taapsee Pannu
Director: Vetrimaaran
Producer: Kathiresan S
1. Yathe Yathe
Singer: Prakash Kumar GV
Lyricist: Snegan
2. Otha Sollaala
Singer: Velmurugan
Lyricist: Yegathasi
3. Porkkalam (Tamil-Rap)
Singer: Yogi B
Lyricist: Yuga Bharathi
4. En Vennilave
Singer: Kay Kay
Lyricist: Jayapalan
5. Ayyayo
Singers: Balasubrahmanyam SP, Charan SPB, Prashanthini
6. Warriors (English Rap)
Singer: Yogi B
Lyricist: Yogi B
7. A Love Blossoms (Instrumental)
Singer: Naveen Iyer
http://www.musicindiaonline.com/#/al...ukalam__2010_/
Anniyan-'Thappu enna baniyan size-ah small, medium,large-nu'Quote:
Originally Posted by NormalMan
IR has directly lifted Yanni's piece for the bgm in KAsturimaan :D
Suresh, before calling him g.v plagiarism kumar, why dont you post the video on his FB's wall and see what he has to say abt this? It may be even Vetri's idea to use the bgmQuote:
Originally Posted by sureshmehcnit
The instrumentation may be the slightest of similar but the notes are completely different. I don't consider it being a direct lift or as you addressed "ripped off".Quote:
Originally Posted by sureshmehcnit
one among the many, but anyway, lets use this thread to discuss GVP's music positively.Quote:
Originally Posted by Mahen
That name G.V.Plagiarism Kumar I read somewhere in the net, and I just used it. I like G.V.Prakash's songs just as much as any of his hard core fans do. And yes, this could also have happened because of Vetri Maaran's insistence. I can perfectly understand that. Even if that is the case, is it so difficult for a composer to convince the director to use a original composition for a background score cue, that runs for less than a minute?Quote:
Originally Posted by Mahen
Hi all, Ilaiyaraaja is a Palgiarism Raaja. I have said it. Now, all the fame and respect he has earned in 35 years of his career is going to crumble.Quote:
Originally Posted by Mahen
:lol:
Remember what he said in interviews about 'Remix'. He even denied to do a remix song in Polladhavan.
Remix pannuradhE thoraikku gowrava koraichal - appadindra pothu BGM lift mattum othukittaraakkum :lol2:
He has even credited remote resemblances to films like Cache, Virumaandi etc., correct-aa? Ivlo pannavar idhai panna maattaaraa? Haven't seen the film, pOttirunthaa santhOsam.Quote:
Originally Posted by Mahen
And GVP has a proven track record of suffufying BGMs in most of his films.
Ilaiyaraaja pOtta 5000 paattulayum, 1000 BGMlayum oru 10 thErumaa? Copied? GVP has what 20 films? And he has been copying very regularly. What a lame comparison :clap:
Ungaluku terinjathu 10, there may be even more :D IR time-le technology konjam kammi, suttalum yarukum teriyathuQuote:
Originally Posted by Nerd
Anyway my point is whether u suttify 1 or 100, it is still SUTTUFYING..justification ellam thevai illai :)
:lol: ennamO 1982-la pOtta paatta appo mattum dhaan ketta maadhiri solreenga. Ippo koodathaan ellaarum kekkuraainga in various music channels, FM radios etcQuote:
Originally Posted by Mahen
What were you trying to do w.r.to GVP's suttuthal? Vetri asked him to? Thats not called "susstipication" :lol: :lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by Mahen
And the GVP-IR comparison w.r.to plagiarism is getting lamer. I retire.
Even for a not-so-big-fan-of-western-music like me, GVP's lifts are embarrassing and he does that often at this young age. Why, is he THAT unimaginative?
He does come up with nice songs once in a while but his BGMs are nothing to speak of. And am I the only one in hub who does not think much of Pookkal pookkum tharunam?
Me, Nerd. i Find pookal pookam tharunam very very plain. no life, soul nor love in that song. The ONLY good thing in the song is Roop Kumar Rathod. When he goes in high pitch, it just gives u the goosebumps....Quote:
Originally Posted by Nerd
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nerd
I am with you on Pookum Pookum Tharunam.. Nothing to rave about
Seriously cant put this in a better way other than calling this comparison lame.
:goodidea:Quote:
Originally Posted by Nerd
Now, lets get back to GV Prakash, the MD of this decade :thumbsup:
What are the other movies on the pipeline for GVP other than Muppozuthum un karpanaikal?
I agree GVP giving some good songs here and there.. but he is copying way too much. We can rate him after Devas, Rajkumars he is right up there siting next to them.
Nerd, yaarume uthaman illai athan en point :)
Nov, hes working with director Vijay with Vikram as the hero and 2 hindi films :)
oh appdiya..pls list down 5 songs that has been copied..copy-na must be exact copy..similar tunes/inspiration ellam rejected..AFIAIK, suriyan(vellithirai) and theddiya(Va quater) are direct lifts..Suriyan song was requested by the director and im not sure abt thediyaQuote:
Originally Posted by mahen01
Just take his Ayirathil Oruvan, musically it was outstanding..on par with an ARR album..If you can prove that he suttufy any of the songs from the album, i'll admit he has miles to go :)
Thanks Mahen.
Dont waste time arguing; you know why some ppl are spiteful.
Agreed. After all u r his fan :)Quote:
Originally Posted by Mahen
Vehemently disagree as an ARR fan. :evil:Quote:
Originally Posted by Mahen
This is an insult. U r doing the same thing what Kamal did to MSV and Raja.
:sigh2: marupadiyum aarambaththilirundhaa? :sigh2:
why cant you leave ppl alone with their opinions ajay?
I think MSV, IR and ARR are all past their prime.
GVP is current.
:lol:
Ok. Let's leave it here.. :D
I understand that why NOV promoting GVP in Hub :lol:
I don't know what you understand San, but I always stand for the underdogs. Once upon a time it was for ARR, then Harris and now GVP. ;)
Anyway, this thread is for GVP.
How would an IR fan feel if someone comes and continually posts negative stuff in his thread?
paathu shock adikka pOguthu..Quote:
Originally Posted by NOV
music dhAn mukkiyamE thavira underdog overcat ellAm mukkiyam illai. This shows that you evaluate not based on musical quality but sociological factors like whether the aprticular MD is an underdog or not.Quote:
I don't know what you understand San, but I always stand for the underdogs. Once upon a time it was for ARR, then Harris and now GVP.
I was about to observe the same but you said it yourself.
You said ARR, Harris and now GVP. Do you remmeber you used to champion YSR also once? From that time your argument has been fanboys of "<Some Titan of an MD>" underrate this boy so I will support him. Not like this boy makes high quality music on par with the titans at their peak and so I support him.
enakku underdog, titan, award winner, overlord ellAm mukkiyam illai. Only inherent quality as I percieve it. In other words, I am holier than thou :poke:
not so fast plum. :P
every one and their neighbour know that GVP is excelling now. if he is not, I wouldnt bother.
irunthum ppl are being spiteful on his success becos he happens to be not one of their favs, or theirs favourite's vaarisu. :poke:
I like Yuvan (and still continue to) but his record post Paiyya has not been impressive, thus my silence. ;)
True..i wonder why :roll:Quote:
Originally Posted by NOV
Mahen,
Avaru solraarunnu neengalum thalai aattureenga? Nobody has a grudge on GVP and why shud anybody have? Ppl here have always celebrated good music. VS for Magizhchchi, Eeram, Mundhinam Paarthene for Thaman, etc. Avanga yaar vaarisu?
Ajay,
Even when he made his debut in Veeyil, many werent happy because his 'easy entry' to the film world...
One hubber interz just hates him..claiming that he doesnt like his music(his composing style)..one of the weirdest reason i have heard..
AO was a rocking album and musically it was outstanding..pls tell me one album(exclude ARR's) that could match AO last year...im only talking about quality here not the commercial success of the song :) appadi irumthum, he has miles to go solringe :( like as if Yuvan/Harris/Thaman/VA are in a different level and GVP is an amateur
Yuvan/Harris/VS are in a higher level. Easily.
GVP is in class of DSP, Thaman and rest..
Cant agree with you :) For me all of them are equally inconsistent..
Mahen,
I am not sure abt ur place. But here in India, some movies or sold banking on the name of the composers. Prices may vary according to the ranks. And that dictates their pay cheques too. HJ and Yuvan have attained that status but not GVP. Thats y i mentioned that he has a long way to go.
and what has that got to do with music?
anyway, GVP is far ahead of IR and ARR :lol2:
As the thread's title has lost its real meaning over the last few days since everyone are discussing other TFM MDs.
I like to say, I favour Thaman in the race of the current generation DOT
I thought u were referring to his music :)Quote:
Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
NOV, comedy pannatinge :x
Mahen, tell me this. How does not liking GVp(which i didnt claim anyway) only because someone is an ir or arr fan. Enna logicyA idhu? Ungalukku pudichirukku so maththavangaLukku pudikkalainA they have agenda? Isnt this a fanatical view from you and nov? Idhula maththavangaLa ir/arr fanaticnu solla vENdiyadhu? Look at the mirror, gents.
take it easy plum... all these were not directed at you. :P
Plumji, when did i say that? :roll:Quote:
Originally Posted by Plum