And very 'Gopiyarga;' is very much Desh.
Printable View
And very 'Gopiyarga;' is very much Desh.
I love the Oranjaro song - which is probably the first Raaja-desh I have heard. The 2nd one I heard is ennai kavrndhizhutha ramanan, which i loved a lot. It is indeed a great composition. Long time since i revisited that.
Good list there!
RR,
I am also having the same feeling.
Was discussing with a musician friend of mine and said that in film music I tend to get confused with Kapi and Desh and sometimes Brindavana Saranga.(Doesn't happen in Carnatic music) He said that all three share the same arohanam and all three have both the nishadams. So if the music director is playing with these common notes, you can hear whichever ragam you want :)
Suresh,
I think Desh and B.Saranga are close in terms of notes but they have so special prayogas that it's not hard to spot one from the other - if the MD is doing justice and not trying to confuse ;) . But kapi is a different animal IMO. It can take more notes than just S R2 M1 P N3, so should be less confusing. As you said, it's clear cut in carnatic but needs closer attention in films.
RR,
The problem is the higher registers. All three would be sharing the same notes in the Ni sa ri ni range. Since both nishadhams appear here, if the MD is doing the arohanam and is hovering around the Ni sa ri ni phrase, I think there will be scope for confusion :)
This is from aathma -- i used to think this is as sudhasaveri or durga, but got from a radio program that this is gowda malhar. A great song!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MhfDQkRrnXs
Sarasamukhi sakala bhagya -- http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4YTy8dAQfyk
Suresh, you may not have heard this one before - VAazhkai Odam Sella from Aval Appadithaan. In a cult movie that didn't get popular acclaim, this song is buried well beneath the phenomenal UravugaL Thodargadhai and Kamal-powered panneer pushpabgaLE. Strong hindustani flavour - a type of song that he stopped the production line in 80s itself. KEttuttu sollunga. Atleast this one I knew before but there is a total, unknown song from the same movie which I discovered only recently - "adi aatha aatha" - rumbunctious is the word that comes to mind. Total riot - kuththu pAttula ivLO sangadhi vekka mudiyumA?