Does some one have shiva 2006 bgms ripped into mp3?
if so...pls upload them....will be a great help! excellent bgm by raaja in the recent past!
thanks in advance.....
Printable View
Does some one have shiva 2006 bgms ripped into mp3?
if so...pls upload them....will be a great help! excellent bgm by raaja in the recent past!
thanks in advance.....
Searched google and came up with R.Bhaskaran as the director. I thought it was a BM movie going by the picturisation/dialogue style.Quote:
Originally Posted by tvsankar
This is a shocker :shock:
I recently came to know there was a don/billa remake in telugu in 1979 titled 'Yugandhar' in which NTR acted in the lead role :roll: and Raaja composed the music for the movie. This was his first direct telugu and only movie for NTR i presume.
After a long search i got hold of the songs and.....
http://www.mediafire.com/?8j4yjxmbzne
This was a shock for me listening 'Ye Rabba vesukunna' which is a blatant lift from 'Kaike Paan banaras waala' :cry: Usually Raaja just gets inspired and takes cue from the original and composes in his own way. But here is song which is a lift from tune/BGM and everything. Apart from 'Kanavu kaanum' This becomes a complete lift and interestingly both songs are composed by Kalyanji-Anandji.
i've read long time back that IR had to oblige to the producer/actor since he had no hold/control over the tunes selection (as he did have in the 80s). i also think that u cant call that a 'lift' if it is a remake unless it is used in a different movie. (we all know how BM was the main reason why "kanavu kaanum" was used, despite IR's resistance).
If such soundtrack has IR as the MD (i.e. without acknowledging the original) then it is HIS lift! If there is acknowledgement (like in the case of remix, 'pazhaya pAdal pOla, pudhiya pAdal illai'), then we can dwell in the circumstances. Otherwise, let's accept it as a lift (and not too much worry about why he had to do it etc.)
We are talking about a film MD here who had to lift to survive / become popular, whatever the circumstances were (and however classy composer he may be). I don't agree to two different yardsticks for Raja and others in calling a lift a lift.
Having said that, his greatness is measured today by his original works and unique contibutions and not each and everyone of his film songs (though the greatness is brought down a little bit every now and then by such revelations)...
:exactly:Quote:
Originally Posted by app_engine
:clap: :clap: :clap:Quote:
Originally Posted by app_engine
:2thumbsup: :2thumbsup: :2thumbsup:Quote:
Originally Posted by app_engine
:cry: :cry: :cry:Quote:
Originally Posted by app_engine
i do respect app_engine's views though i still hold mine. to me, 'akkarai cheemai' is a lift but yuganthar song is not.
btw, shouldnt we be discussing this in the 'Copying' thread? :-)
am still waiting for some good soul to post these :
'dhoori dhoori' (SJ version) - thendral sudum
'chinna kanmanikkulley' - paattu paadavaa
RS & fans,
Here is the Real Salute movie file (in FLV format).
http://rapidshare.com/files/78037574...alute.flv.html
If you want to convert it into mp4 for viewing in iPod, etc. download the free YouTube to iPod Converter from www.dvdvideosoft.com.
Thanks a lot CRV :)Quote:
Originally Posted by crvenky